Payments for Astro: what 34 makers' products chose
Among 34 makers' products built with Astro that we know the payments of, Stripe leads: 22 of them (65%). Next come Paddle (5) and Polar (3).
Payment processor or merchant of record (MoR). With a processor you are the seller and must register for and remit sales tax/VAT yourself. An MoR resells your product, so tax and compliance are theirs, for a higher fee.
What makers on Astro chose
| Option | Astro products | All makers | Free for | At 10,000 users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 (65%) | 77% | ~23 users | $410/moStandard | |
| 5 (15%) | 7% | ~13 users | $700/moPay-as-you-go | |
| 3 (9%) | 4% | ~13 users | $560/moPro | |
| 3 (9%) | 7% | ~13 users | $700/moStandard | |
| 2 (6%) | 8% | ~18 users | $495/moStandard card payments |
Live makers' products with a source for both: that they're built with Astro, and what they use for payments. A product using two options counts in both; not market share. "All makers" is the option's share among every maker's product that made this decision.
Costs are the cheapest plan that fits, from each vendor's pricing page, at the usage our stack planner assumes for a product with that many users. Free for: the users its cheapest plan a business can use stays free for; plans for personal use only, like a non-commercial hobby tier, don't count.
Which to pick, by situation
- You sell mainly in one country or can handle sales tax yourself, and want the lowest fees
Stripe 22 here - You're a developer selling SaaS subscriptions or license keys worldwide and don't want to register for tax
Polar 3 here
Lemon Squeezy 3 here - Your SaaS already has steady revenue and you want to hand off global tax to a long-established MoR
Paddle 5 here - Your AI product charges by usage and sells to customers in many countries
Polar 3 here - Many of your buyers are consumers who expect a PayPal button at checkout
PayPal 2 here
Stripe
Payment processor22 Astro products here (65%). Free up to about 23 users. About $410 a month at 10,000 users (Standard).
llms.txtMCPCLIIn Bolt, Lovable, Replit, v0Best forFull control over checkout and billing, lower fees than a merchant of record, and the widest integration ecosystem.
Trade-offYou are the merchant of record — tax registration and filings are on you.
“Its simple integration and user-friendly dashboard make it easy for us to manage subscriptions, track payments, and handle billing with minimal effort.”
- Subscriptions, trials, invoices, refunds and taxes are handled in one place, so founders skip building billing. 4 sources
- The APIs, webhooks and documentation are reliable and accurate enough to feel like a product themselves. 4 sources
- Sudden revenue jumps can trigger balance freezes with slow reviews and no stated reason. 4 sources
- Merchant fees become painful at scale, and merchant-of-record style services cost much more than plain processing. 3 sources
“Its simple integration and user-friendly dashboard make it easy for us to manage subscriptions, track payments, and handle billing with minimal effort.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“Stripe powers iVox license sales. Had payments and checkout working in a day. The dashboard alone is worth it.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“One of the OG tools with world class integrations”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“Stripe is the payment infra for Sell to State”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“Picked Stripe in about 30 seconds. Subscription primitives, Stripe Tax for global compliance, and a developer experience that's still the bar everyone else is judged against. The Stripe MCP server was a bonus — being able to query live subscription data from Claude during development cut a lot of dashboard-flipping out of my workflow. For a solo founder shipping a SaaS, there isn't a real second choice.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“Billing for the studio's Free / Starter / Pro plans. Checkout, the customer portal, failed-renewal dunning, webhooks — all the parts that take weeks to build yourself, wired in days. The portal in particular saves a whole settings page from existing.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗
Paddle
Merchant of record5 Astro products here (15%). Free up to about 13 users. About $700 a month at 10,000 users (Pay-as-you-go).
In LovableBest forEstablished SaaS businesses that want a mature MoR.
Trade-offStricter onboarding and domain review before you can sell.
“Paddle’s checkout and reporting let us focus on product, not VAT forms. Smooth setup, great docs, and rock-solid reliability.”
- As merchant of record it remits VAT and sales tax everywhere and handles refunds and disputes. 3 sources
- Subscriptions, overlay checkout, the customer portal and a sandbox for testing come in one integration. 2 sources
- Accounts can be frozen at review time with payouts held for months. 2 sources
- Onboarding verification is long and asks for company documents before you can sell. 2 sources
Status page: 2 incidents in the last 90 days, 1 major (its own page, 2026-10-19).
“Seamlessly handles all our payment processing, making it easy to focus on building rather than billing complexities.”
PaymentsMaker says so +1 · source ↗“Paddle’s checkout and reporting let us focus on product, not VAT forms. Smooth setup, great docs, and rock-solid reliability.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗
Polar
Merchant of record3 Astro products here (9%). Free up to about 13 users. About $560 a month at 10,000 users (Pro).
llms.txtBest forDevelopers selling SaaS, subscriptions, usage-based plans or license keys.
Trade-offNewer than Paddle or Lemon Squeezy.
“Using this for payments. Switched from some fruit based one. Much simpler and support has been great.”
- As merchant of record it takes on global sales tax, so solo founders sell worldwide without a compliance setup. 1 source
- Works for sole traders in countries without Stripe and needs no company set up first. 2 sources
“Polar understands SaaS pricing for developers. Their webhook system is reliable, customer portal is built-in, and founder pricing tiers were trivial to implement. Better developer experience than Stripe's complexity, with transparent pricing and no surprise fees. Perfect for indie SaaS launching with transparent pricing models.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“Using this for payments. Switched from some fruit based one. Much simpler and support has been great.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“Easy integration with good API docs.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗
Lemon Squeezy
Merchant of record3 Astro products here (9%). Free up to about 13 users. About $700 a month at 10,000 users (Standard).
Best forSelling software and digital downloads with minimal setup.
Trade-offStripe is moving this work to Stripe Managed Payments and plans to migrate Lemon Squeezy users there; support and updates have slowed.
“Selling worldwide as a solo dev would've meant drowning in tax and licensing. Lemon Squeezy's Merchant-of-Record model let me ship DockDuck globally and never touch VAT.”
- As merchant of record it handles VAT, sales tax and invoicing across countries for solo developers. 1 source
- Pays individuals directly without a registered company, including in regions Stripe does not serve. 2 sources
- Store applications get rejected without a specific reason or sit in review for weeks. 4 sources
- Since the Stripe acquisition, development looks stalled and the service feels like it has declined. 4 sources
“Selling worldwide as a solo dev would've meant drowning in tax and licensing. Lemon Squeezy's Merchant-of-Record model let me ship DockDuck globally and never touch VAT.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗“LemonSqueezy simplifies payment and subscription management, providing a comprehensive solution for digital product monetization.”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗
PayPal
Payment processor2 Astro products here (6%). Free up to about 18 users. About $495 a month at 10,000 users (Standard card payments).
llms.txtMCPBest forAdding PayPal and Venmo as a checkout option for buyers who won't type in a card.
Trade-offYou are still the merchant of record for tax; disputes and account holds are a common complaint, and its developer tools are clunkier than Stripe's.
“Listed in their tool stack on Starter Story (payments)”
- Simple to add as a payment option on a basic website, and a common backup checkout next to a card processor. 3 sources
- Accounts and funds get frozen or permanently locked with vague or no explanation. 4 sources
- Buyers are pushed to have a PayPal account, which adds checkout friction and raises cart abandonment. 1 source
“Listed in their tool stack on Starter Story (payments)”
PaymentsMaker says so · source ↗Also chosen, and not seen yet
Real options for payments not seen among these Astro products yet: Dodo Payments.
Who switches, and to what
Public GitHub pull requests whose title says "X to Y", by developers in general, not only on Astro.
- Stripe → Paddle 18 pull requests
- Stripe → Polar 12 pull requests
- Stripe → PayPal 9 pull requests
- Lemon Squeezy → Paddle 6 pull requests
- PayPal → Stripe 6 pull requests
- Lemon Squeezy → Stripe 5 pull requests
Getting payments right
Solo makers selling globally usually start with a merchant of record to avoid tax registration. Move to a processor when volume makes the fee difference matter and you can handle tax (e.g. with Stripe Tax).
- Choosing a processor to save a few percent, then finding out you crossed sales tax or VAT thresholds in places you never registered.
- Granting access from the checkout success redirect instead of the webhook, so a closed tab leaves a paying customer locked out.
- Handling only the first payment and ignoring failed renewals and cancellations, so users keep access after they stop paying.
The rest of the Astro stack
What makers' Astro products chose for their other decisions, the most common pick for each:
- Hosting: Vercel 49 of 112
- Transactional Email: Resend 44 of 84
- Web Analytics: Cloudflare Web Analytics 18 of 47
- Database: Supabase 7 of 27
- LLM API: OpenAI API 17 of 27
- Product Analytics: PostHog 13 of 14
- Authentication: Clerk 8 of 12
- Speech-to-Text & Text-to-Speech: ElevenLabs 7 of 12
Questions
What do most Astro apps use for payments?
Among 34 makers' products built with Astro that we know the payments of, Stripe leads: 22 of them (65%). Next come Paddle (5) and Polar (3).
What does payments cost for an Astro app with 10,000 users?
On our usage model at 10,000 users, Stripe comes to about $410 a month (Standard); Paddle comes to about $700 a month (Pay-as-you-go); Polar comes to about $560 a month (Pro); Lemon Squeezy comes to about $700 a month (Standard). Prices are from each vendor's pricing page.
Which payments option stays free longest for an Astro app?
Stripe: on our usage model its cheapest plan stays free up to about 23 users.
How this is counted: a product is on Astro when a live-product source says so (the maker, its website, a customer story or a subprocessor list), and the same for its payments. How evidence is collected.