Updated

Amazon S3

AWS's object storage service for storing and retrieving any amount of data via API, with multiple storage tiers.

206 open-source projects declare Amazon S3 in their code; no maker's live product we track uses it yet. What makers like most: Its API has become the standard that many other storage tools and self-hosted servers implement. Their most common complaint: Storage costs far more than cheap servers or S3-compatible alternatives, and a missing VPC endpoint can cause surprise bills.

No free tierPaid from Pay as you go

Profile checked

Works with AI agents:Built into Lovable
Ask your AI about this, with this page as the source:ChatGPT ↗Claude ↗Perplexity ↗

How makers use Amazon S3

What Amazon S3 is used for

File Storage · Object storage →Apps already on AWS, or ones that need lifecycle rules, storage tiers and event triggers.Trade-off: Egress fees add up when files are downloaded a lot, and IAM setup is fiddly for one person.
Cloudflare R24Supabase3Uppy2MinIO1Amazon S30Makers' products on each, for file storage

Amazon S3 vs the alternatives makers chose

OptionMakers' productsFree forAt 10,000 usersOpen source
Cloudflare R24 40%~7,700 users$1.35/mo · R2 StandardNo
Supabase3 30%~100 users$25/mo · ProYes
Uppy2 20%——Yes
MinIO1 10%——Yes
Amazon S30 0%~4,300 users$11/mo · S3 Standard (US East)No

For file storage: how many of the 10 makers' products we know the file storage of chose each option, and what each costs at 10,000 users.

Costs are the cheapest plan that fits, from each vendor's pricing page, at the usage our stack planner assumes for a product with that many users. Free for: the users its cheapest plan a business can use stays free for.

When to use Amazon S3, and when not

Pick Amazon S3 if

  • You're already on AWS, or want old files moved to cheaper tiers and uploads to trigger processing. File Storage →

Something else fits better if

  • Your users' images, video or downloads are fetched a lot by the public: Cloudflare R2.
  • You're in a TypeScript app and want uploads working today without wiring presigned URLs: UploadThing.
  • You host a Next.js app on Vercel and don't want another account: Vercel Blob.
  • Your backend is on Supabase and who can see a file depends on who owns the data: Supabase.
From each decision's guide, written from what makers' products chose and why.

Amazon S3 is AWS's object storage: you put files (objects) into buckets and read them back by key over an HTTP API. Apps use it for user uploads, static assets, backups and logs, and many other storage services copy its API.

More about Amazon S3

Each general purpose bucket lives in one AWS Region you choose; objects stay there unless you copy or replicate them, and in most storage classes they are stored across at least three Availability Zones. Reads after a write or delete are strongly consistent. Access is governed by IAM and bucket policies, and new buckets are private, with Block Public Access on and ACLs disabled. You call it through the AWS SDKs (JavaScript, Python, Go, Java, .NET, PHP, Ruby, Rust, Swift and others) or the CLI, and give browsers presigned URLs for direct uploads and downloads.

For a small team, the useful parts are storage classes from Standard to Glacier archive tiers, plus Intelligent-Tiering, with lifecycle rules that move or expire objects automatically; versioning and Object Lock to undo or prevent overwrites and deletions; event notifications to Lambda, SQS or SNS when objects change; and replication to other Regions. It runs only in AWS's cloud.

The main cost is the AWS surface itself: IAM, policies and billing by request and transfer take time to learn. The built-in static website endpoint serves plain HTTP, so HTTPS or a custom domain means putting CloudFront in front.

Amazon S3 pros and cons

What makers like most: Its API has become the standard that many other storage tools and self-hosted servers implement. Their most common complaint: Storage costs far more than cheap servers or S3-compatible alternatives, and a missing VPC endpoint can cause surprise bills.

Pros

  • Its API has become the standard that many other storage tools and self-hosted servers implement. HNHN 2HN 3HN 4
  • Data is stored redundantly across separate datacenters, and AWS uses formal methods to check S3's correctness. HNHN 2
  • It keeps adding primitives like conditional writes and automatic request scaling that other tools build on. HNHN 2

Cons and watch-outs

  • Storage costs far more than cheap servers or S3-compatible alternatives, and a missing VPC endpoint can cause surprise bills. HNHN 2HN 3
  • Serving files straight from S3 ties you and your customers to AWS, which worries those avoiding US jurisdiction. HNHN 2
  • Regional incidents reach it too: bucket creation depends on us-east-1, and some data in one damaged region was unrecoverable. HNHN 2

Themes that recur in makers' words and Hacker News comments, each linked to what it summarises.

What Hacker News says about Amazon S3

On Hacker News, 8% of comments about Amazon S3 recommend it and 3% criticize it: net praise +5%, 5th best liked of 6 tools HN discusses for file storage.

By year

YearComments choosing it, per monthNet praise
202313+5%
202413+13%
202512−4%
2026 (8 mo)15+4%

In their words

  • “we aggressively avoid tech that isn’t universal (so S3 is OK, but SQS or DynamoDB is not” HN, Apr 2026
  • “S3’s simple setup (which denies all public access) is not flawed in the manner being discussed here.” HN, Nov 2024
  • “S3 has a fair bit of bloat in spec that nobody seems to use” HN, Apr 2026

Hacker News comments January 2023 to August 2026 that name Amazon S3 in a sentence like "I use" or "we moved to", Claude read a sample of 100 and the counts scale it to all of them; net praise is comments recommending it minus comments criticizing it, as a share of all comments about it. How it's counted, and how HN compares with makers.

Who uses it

No maker's live product on record yet, and 206 open-source projects that declare it in their code.

Declared in code 206How evidence is collected →

We haven't found a maker's live product that uses Amazon S3 yet — only the open-source projects below, which declare it in their code.

Open source: a project that declares Amazon S3 as a dependency in its public code — verifiable, but not necessarily a live product.

What its projects tell coding agents

100 of the 136 open-source products built with Amazon S3 that were worked on in the last 180 days keep instruction files for coding agents — 74%, against 53% of all the projects we read. AGENTS.md is in 83, CLAUDE.md in 55.

899words in the median file
pnpmthe package manager most named, in 18 of 88 files
58%say how to test a change
Named more in these files than in other projects' — in how many of the 88:
What AGENTS.md files say about other tools →What open-source products tell their coding agents →

Alternatives to Amazon S3

All alternatives by situation →

Questions makers ask about Amazon S3

What are the pros and cons of Amazon S3?

Pros makers name: Its API has become the standard that many other storage tools and self-hosted servers implement. Data is stored redundantly across separate datacenters, and AWS uses formal methods to check S3's correctness. It keeps adding primitives like conditional writes and automatic request scaling that other tools build on. Cons: Storage costs far more than cheap servers or S3-compatible alternatives, and a missing VPC endpoint can cause surprise bills. Serving files straight from S3 ties you and your customers to AWS, which worries those avoiding US jurisdiction. Regional incidents reach it too: bucket creation depends on us-east-1, and some data in one damaged region was unrecoverable.

What are the alternatives to Amazon S3?

For file storage, the other options makers' products we track chose most are Cloudflare R2 (4), Supabase (3), Uppy (2), MinIO (1). Open source or self-hostable among them: Supabase, Uppy, MinIO. Each alternative, with the situation it fits, is on the Amazon S3 alternatives page.

How much does Amazon S3 cost per month?

At 10,000 users, Amazon S3 costs $11 a month on the cheapest plan that fits (S3 Standard (US East)), from its pricing page.

When should you use Amazon S3?

You're already on AWS, or want old files moved to cheaper tiers and uploads to trigger processing (file storage). Something else fits better if: your users' images, video or downloads are fetched a lot by the public, pick Cloudflare R2; you're in a TypeScript app and want uploads working today without wiring presigned URLs, pick UploadThing.

Where is my data stored?

In the AWS Region you pick when creating the bucket. Most storage classes spread objects across at least three Availability Zones in that Region; One Zone-IA keeps them in a single zone. source ↗

Is there an uptime SLA?

Yes. The S3 SLA pays service credits if monthly uptime falls below the commitment; S3 Standard is designed for 99.99% availability, and the infrequent-access classes for less. source ↗

Are new buckets public?

No. Buckets and objects are private by default, Block Public Access is turned on at the bucket level, and ACLs are disabled so access is managed only through policies. source ↗

Can I host a static site on S3 with HTTPS?

Not from the S3 website endpoint alone, which does not support HTTPS. AWS's answer is to serve the bucket through CloudFront, or through Amplify Hosting. source ↗

How long can a presigned upload or download URL stay valid?

Up to seven days when signed with an IAM user's credentials. If it was signed with temporary credentials, such as an IAM role, it stops working when that session expires, whatever expiry you set. source ↗

Can I store health data (HIPAA) in S3?

S3 is on AWS's list of HIPAA-eligible services, but you must sign a business associate agreement with AWS before using it for protected health information. source ↗

Do I pay egress if I move all my data off AWS?

Eligible customers can get free data transfer out when leaving AWS entirely, but only after contacting AWS Support for pre-approval; approved moves receive a temporary credit. source ↗

Is Amazon S3 free?

No permanent free tier; paid use starts at Pay as you go. source ↗

Is Amazon S3 open source or self-hostable?

Not open source, and hosted only.

Can AI coding agents work with Amazon S3?

Lovable set it up natively.

Who uses Amazon S3?

No maker's live product we track yet; 206 open-source projects declare it in their code. source ↗