# Hacker News on developer tools, 2023-01 to 2026-08

The labels behind https://howmakersbuild.com/reports/hn-tools-2026-11: what Hacker News commenters do with the tools they name — recommend, use, criticize, only mention — read by Claude.

## Files

- `labels.jsonl` — 14,700 lines, one per comment and tool it names (a comment naming two tools has two lines):
  - `comment`, `url`: the Hacker News comment id and link
  - `month`: when it was posted (YYYY-MM); `story`: the title of the story it sits under ("" when not found)
  - `tool`, `tool_name`: the tool, by its slug on howmakersbuild.com (https://howmakersbuild.com/tools/<slug>)
  - `stance`: `recommends` (tells others to use it, or praises it from their own use), `uses` (says they use or used it, no clear verdict), `criticizes` (complains, warns others off, or left it over a problem), `mentions` (names it without using or judging it), `not_tool` (the word means something else here: a for-loop, not Loops)
  - `switched_to`: when the commenter says they moved off this tool to another tool named in the same comment, that tool's slug; else null
  - `quote`: the shortest span of the comment, at most 20 words, that shows the stance ("" for mentions and not_tool)
- `tools.json` — per tool: the labels counted, per year, and each year's counts scaled up to all the matching comments that year (see below)

## How it was made

1. Every comment in the open-index/hacker-news archive (https://huggingface.co/datasets/open-index/hacker-news, ODC-By) from 2023-01 to 2026-08 that names one of the tools we track for a set of build decisions (database, hosting, sign-in, frontend, model APIs, coding agents and more) in a sentence that usually signals a choice — "I use", "we moved to", "recommend", "avoid" — 76,135 comments.
2. Up to 25 per tool and year, spread over the months, 12,846 comments in all, each labeled by Claude Sonnet 5.5 for every tool it names, with the story title as context.
3. In tools.json, a year's counts scale its labeled share to that year's matching comments.

## Know before you use it

- The labels are a model's reading, not checked by hand. On a 60-comment trial, two Claude models agreed on 76% of labels; most disagreements were between `uses`, `mentions` and `recommends`.
- Only comments with a choice-like phrase are in; HN discussion that never says "I use" or "avoid" isn't.
- A tool's comments cover everything it does (Supabase's are mostly about its database), and comments about a company's chat app (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini) count toward its model API.
- No usernames are kept. Comment text appears only as the short quote; follow the link for the rest.

## License

ODC-By 1.0, like the archive it comes from: use it for anything; credit "How Makers Build (howmakersbuild.com), from the open-index/hacker-news archive".
